Rate the artist above you

[Coolio]

Everyone should get the jist of this. You rate the person above you's work and how good they are at graphics. Use novice, intermediate, & pro and all rankings in between. Comment on what you think of their work and how you think they can improve.

P.S. Please no one take offence to what is said about you this is just for a bit of fun.

[buckeyefan]

definitally pro, coolio has done some amazing stuff.

[Tribunal]

intermediate, you're still just a step above novice, but you're diffenetly comming along.

[Vision.Pro]

Intermediate, One of the better artist on this site, but still in need of improvement to become a pro

[Coolio]

Vision.Pro, medium Pro. Good at His style but some subtle things would crank up his rank even more

[Skribble]

I was going to do Vision, but Coolio beat me, Vision - Advanced.... Coolio - Intermediate, your good but yeh.

[Tribunal]

Intermediate, One of the better artist on this site, but still in need of improvement to become a pro

son of a *****, I get the most critical member of the forums lol.

Coolio, you have outstanding signatures, but, from how I've seen them I've liked one out of the last 3 you've had (the one I like being the one you're using right now) which I would say puts you in intermediate, however, you DO seem to have alot of knowledge of the inner workings of the program, so I say it puts you at low pro.

EDIT: Skribble beat me to it.

Skribble is diffenetly a pro.

who ever rates me next, keep in mind. I have fans!!! don't mess with me! 8) :lol:

[Voice Of A Riot]

Tribunal I'd say your in a transition between intermediate and pro...border line pro. I've really liked your sigs recently.

[Firefox]

every one is a pro in this thread, and Vision.Pro I think is the best designer in the forums.

[Skribble]

Firefox is a Beginner with skill.

[Tribunal]

every one is a pro in this thread, and Vision.Pro I think is the best designer in the forums.

aye, I'd have to agree, I gotten messages from maybe... 7-8 people who say I'm the best on the forums, and I always ask them "Have you even looked at vision pro?" Point them to the Death of America Photom and I think they'd get the point.

Skribble again is a pro.

[Thorzilla]

Hey there:
Quite a good idea about this topic coolio. However we should make a rating system like:
Beginner
Beginner+
Intermediate
Intermediate+
Advanced
Advanced+
Pro

For tribunal i give it an advanced rating. Really good sigs and avatars, but some room for improvement yet.
Keep it up D.S.!
OVER.

See ya!

[Skribble]

Thorzilla, you've been making alot lately, and I've seen notable improvement from the start to now, you still have a way to go though, intermediate...

[Coolio]

Skribble I really like a lot of your workbut there is room for improvement. (With the use of thorzilla's rating system) Advanced+

Oh btw take the anti-aliasing off that pixel font in your sig

[Skribble]

It's not dark because of the aliasing...

Coolio - Advanced

[buckeyefan]

skribble, advanced + pro... prolly in the top 2 for best artist in the forums.

[Silas]

Intermediate, i used to have a sig by you, it was very good! You just need more practice!

(I have never tried doing graphics so i think i can be called a Graphics Virgin)

[Firefox]

Silas: have you ever even touched photoshop? :lol:

[Silas]

Nope, i don't think they have a mac version. I may be suprised though, they had a Net Explorer mac version. Is there one? (The only graphics thing i have ever done is Mac paint!)

[Tribunal]

Firefox I'll give you hmmm, Intermediate on Thorzillas list, you're not great. But your not bad either.

[Firefox]

Tribunal, definetly a pro one of the best on the forums in terms of making sigs.
Silas go to the adobe cs2 site and download the trial version, the first box that
says download is the mac version, look forward to seeing what you can do :P

[Silas]

:lol: I'll be on the design team in no time! btw: Where have you been?

[Skribble]

Just as proof that Photoshop is a mac product...

A print screen of photoshop starting up, opened in photoshop and a screenshot taken of that!

http://i4.photobucket.com/albums/y123/Skribbledesigns/Picture2.png



Excessive, YES! Pointless? YES! Will I shut up now? YES!

[The House]

Here is a question for you guys, who made the most sigs that are used right now by the members? yes this is offtopic.

[soldier one]

should a make and post a pic of mine for this? :D
i rate you intermidiate because everyone has room to improve, you are great.

[Thorzilla]

Hey there:
As i never seen any soldier one sig, i will rate firefox.
I like the killzone signature, but the signature you did for soldier one is a bit stretched from up to down.
Intermediate, but a lot of room to improve though.
Keep up the good work as SMC too!
OVER.

See ya!

[soldier one]

http://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y204/s1s2s3s4s5/sun1.jpg
ill give a few one firefox might reconize. :D
http://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y204/s1s2s3s4s5/SIGGGGGGG.jpg
a basic one i made a while ago. for grim reaper
http://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y204/s1s2s3s4s5/disturbed-1.jpg
one i made for my liking a while back.

[Thorzilla]

Hey there:
Hmm...they look a bit blurry and a bit pasted.
But the effect of the "GodSmack" one, blending in with the background is good.
I would give you a begginer+ as begginers like when i started did not know the "copy>paste" technique. (OMG i was so dumb bck then :roll: )
OVER.

See ya!

[Tribunal]

Here is a question for you guys, who made the most sigs that are used right now by the members? yes this is offtopic.

Good question, I think I only have 4 on people right now.

I Believe Thorzilla probably has the most out. Or NoUseMerc from the days of old.

[Thorzilla]

Hey there:
:lol: :lol: :lol: Good joke tribunal. I guess it is you the one that has more people using your signatures.
Tribunal, sorry for this but i think you are Advanced+...JK
Your signatures are really good, and if you may have time someday, i would feel honored to be given some advices from you or any DSmember :D
BTW i dont know if you meant it, but i will take what you said as a compliment (dunno why though)
OVER.

See ya!

[Firefox]

hmmm....thorzilla, :? I think you are a intermediate+ you have improved really
well.

[NoUseMercenary]

Soldier One's

http://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y204/s1s2s3s4s5/disturbed-1.jpg



Its dada art....lol

[Tribunal]

I give NoUseMercenary a Advanced. That also has to do with the fact that he made the Design Squad in the first place... and he's our leader...hmmm.

Advanced+ :lol: :lol:

[Thorzilla]

This topic is almost diying.
Tribunal=advanced+
Very good signatures and great brushing and blendings.
OVER.

[Vincent_V.]

Thorzilla I think your pretty awesome. I love the Avitar and Signature. Keep up the good work.

[Silas]

*cough* *cough* Sooking up! :lol: Nah, only joking.

Thorzilla have to say you are now an Advanced - (If there is such a thing!)
Vincent_V. I havent seen much of your work beside your avatar so i'd say you are still a begginer.

[Coolio]

Silas and vncent v i havn't seen any of you work... thorzilla I'd call you low intermediate to intermediate. You still have a long way to go

[NoUseMercenary]

I give NoUseMercenary a Advanced. That also has to do with the fact that he made the Design Squad in the first place... and he's our leader...hmmm.

Advanced+ :lol: :lol:

Are you giving me this rating for my sig or my work you have seen over the past few months? Or the post I put earlier with dada art, because thats not mine...it was posted by Soldier One.

[Skribble]

Advanced...

[Firefox]

Thorzilla, 9/10 but you still can improve :D

[Tribunal]

You know this is the rate the artist thread Adam? :lol:

So I'll rate FireFox intermediate, with alot to learn.

[NoUseMercenary]

Your recent work I would move you up to mmm.....intermediate to advanced

[Coolio]

advanced+ :)

[Firefox]

Coolio, definately Advanced...I like how you don't use the techniques that everyone else
uses

[Tribunal]

Intermediate.
I'd say you just barely got passed novice not to long ago.

[Legend Killer]

Firefox intermediate+ you're improving with every sig.
Tribunal: Advance. 8)

[MiNiMaL_sAnItY]

advanced


im not even squat compared to anyone of you people. :oops:

[Coolio]

(I'm reviving this thread since everyone has gotten better)

Low moderate (moderate is before intermediate and after novice)

You're getting better with every sig but you have a long way to go

[UndecideD]

Advanced + you and trib are the best imo.

[Supaman²²³]

Undecided is pretty good just pushing the bounds of Advanced to become Pro.

[boomheadshot45]

Well only legend killer has seen my stuff so, i don't think any of you can rate me. Well i haven't seen any of your supaman i'll just rate undecided. Advanced, your very good and creative

[Coolio]

I havnt seen any from boom or supaman but undecided you're intermediate. By this forums standards you are advanced

[Legend Killer]

Coolio definitely= Advance+
Tribunal= Advance+
UndecideD= Advance
boomheadshot45= Amateur
Firefox= Intermediate

LK= Priceless. :lol: j/k

[boomheadshot45]

^ LK what ever the best is. You are very good. I would have my signaturein but whenever i put it in it goes like this
[img]
then the signature. I have it right i just need the img and the signature all on the same line

[UndecideD]

the code is link here

[MiNiMaL_sAnItY]

UndecideD ill rate you intermediate. :D

[UndecideD]

novice (no offence)
What ever happended to Vision pro. he was a pro imo.

[Supaman²²³]

(i already rated you above)

I decided to bring this puppy back up from the grave.


now that you guys seen my work you rate me.

[Pr0LiFiX]

8/10.
Pretty good, in my opinion. :DD

[Supaman²²³]

You are not an artist therefore i cant rate you

[brett13sa]

I like your sigs Supaman. I'll go...intermediate.

YAY, rate me. :D

[justintheman99]

I like your sig but unfortunately I never saw anything else you did so it is hard to rate. So I guess I will have to say Intermediate. I just started making sigs within the past few weeks. So far I only found time to make 3 with this one being my latest creation. I've done everything in Photoshop but for some reason I never ever got into making sigs. Oh well something new to try out and get better at.

[Tribunal]

I've never seen anything you've made, so I'll just assume you made your last too sigs. I'll give ya a 6/10.

[Supaman²²³]

10/10 One of the best (If not the best) Designers on this site

[MiNiMaL_sAnItY]

7/10. You are getting better by the day. (yeah yeah i remember you kicked my butt in that sig contest) :cry: :x

[justintheman99]

I've never seen anything you've made, so I'll just assume you made your last too sigs. I'll give ya a 6/10.

Yes I did make my last 2 sigs, both were made to overcome boredom at work.

[Supaman²²³]

5/10 your still a beginner with plenty of room to improve

[Tribunal]

7/10 your Design Squad Contest sigs could be alot better...

[MiNiMaL_sAnItY]

10/10. No doubts about it. :lol:

[UndecideD]

7/10
you still need alot of work on your sigs,but you're improving.

[Supaman²²³]

9.9/10 A very good designer! :D

[Tribunal]

UndecideD...

9.9/10...

...

...

:lol: :lol: :lol:

Ok, I had my laugh, we should go back to the actual style of rating this thread is supposed to have.

Supaman_225, you get intermediate.

[Legend Killer]

Supaman 7/10 you've improve alot keep it up.

Tribunal 10/10 no doubt.

[UndecideD]

UndecideD...

9.9/10...

...

...

:lol: :lol: :lol:

Ok, I had my laugh, we should go back to the actual style of rating this thread is supposed to have.

Supaman_225, you get intermediate.
YOu MeAn *i*** :evil:
I think you are high j/k
---------------------------------
Legend Killer you get a high intermediate-whatever is after high intermediate...Low somthing.

[ginno]

10/10 most of what ive seen has been beautiful :D keep up the good work

o ye diffinate PRO lol